Dawkins’ climb up Mount Insufferable

John H Saturday 1st November, AD 2008

A lot of comment this week on Richard Dawkins’ not-at-all-wacked-out decision to step down from his Oxford University post as professor for the Public Understanding of Science in order to write a book warning of the hideous dangers posed to children by imagination and fantasy. (Do you realise some of these fairy tales say a kiss can turn a frog into a prince? Where’s the rationality in that? Did Charles Darwin die in vain? Etc., etc.)

This is not a new concern for Prof Dawkins. At the opening of a chapter in his (superb) 1996 book, Climbing Mount Improbable, he writes as follows:

I was driving through the English countryside with my daughter Juliet, then aged six, and she pointed out some flowers by the wayside. I asked her what she thought wildflowers were for. She gave a rather thoughtful answer. “Two things,” she said. “To make the world pretty, and to help the bees make honey for us.” I was touched by this and sorry I had to tell her it wasn’t true.

My reaction to that now remains the same as when I first read it: “No you weren’t. You enjoyed every moment of it!”

As Jeremy points out, Luther has the best response to this: “Laugh your adversary to scorn … and then joke and play games with [your] wife and others”. So that’s what I’m going to do.

4 Responses to “Dawkins’ climb up Mount Insufferable”

  1. Phil Walkeron 01 Nov 2008 at 12:59 pm

    Ah, but did you see who’s replacing him? Marcus du Sautoy! Mathematicians: we’re taking over the world, I tell ya…

  2. [...] to John H for blogging on [...]

  3. Tom Ron 03 Nov 2008 at 2:09 am

    Well, think of how Britannia will fall behind in embryonic-stemm-cell research if a generation of schoolchildren grow up believing that bears make armour, that witches rule the North Pole, and that angels can fly between alternative worlds…

  4. Tom Ron 03 Nov 2008 at 2:13 am

    Hmmm. So Skinwad thinks Harry Potter is dangerous. He’ll be decamping for Alabamee then? Yip-yah!

    And as for the anti-scientific heresies propounded by “Dr Who”… I think Lalla deserves a spanking for taking part in those.

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply

  • RSS Wandering Hedgehog

  • Archives

  • Meta